Social media chosen as Newsmaker of the Year
The Vancouver Courier chooses social media as 2011’s top newsmaker
I fetched my latest edition of the Vancouver Courier off my front walk, neatly tucked inside a plastic bag to protect it from rainwater. The cover story was one I had been anticipating since, for the second year running, I’d been asked to contribute to the paper’s “Newsmaker of the Year” edition. What pleased me was to see that the Courier team felt as I did: that 2011 was the year where social media (in particular Twitter) came into being as a powerful communications force.
For their ‘top newsmakers’ I had to choose from the following list:
- The downtown casino proposal
- Canucks Stanley Cup run
- Stanley Cup riot
- The election
- Occupy Vancouver
- The key role of social media in civic life
Before making my choice I mulled the list over for a couple of hours. During the year I had commented on all of these topics, and was particularly invested the Vancouver election as you imagine a city council candidate would be. Despite devoting months of my own life to the election, for me it wasn’t the biggest story of the year.
I think in any other year the biggest story should have been the disastrous Stanley Cup riot of June 15th. I have many strong feelings about how and why it happened, and how our elected leaders convincingly shirked any responsibility for their own actions. Such is the power of good public relations. But in the end, it was not my choice either.
As I eyeballed the list the last line about social media stuck out for me. It was awkwardly expressed, but it reminded me of dozens of conversations I’d had over the past year about the impact of bloggers and Twitterers alike. I chose social media because of the way it linked all the suggested topics. I even thought I’d be clever and write my 250-word submission as a series of tweets, but scrapped the idea after a first draft.
Christine Ackermann, president of the West End Residents Association, also agreed that social media was the top newsmaker. Ackermann, who’s no fan of centre-right politics from what I can tell, compliments this blog in her Courier submission, saying:
Consider that the main voice opposing city hall for the last three years has come from CityCaucus.com, an online blog
The power of Twitter, Facebook and online media was best demonstrated this year in the events surrounding the Arab Spring. Time magazine made the protests the subject of their “Person of the Year” selection. Anthony De Rosa, online editor for Reuters news agency recently released this timeline of social media related to the Arab Spring protests, which he says took him two days to compile. It’s a fascinating and revealing account of how social media led to the downfall of several autocratic regimes.
Vancouverites have been some of the world’s earliest adopters and most enthusiastic users of social media. As the Courier points out in its introduction to the Newsmaker feature, some of the biggest social media innovators come from here.
Social media is not new. Social media in Vancouver, the birthplace of Flickr and Hootsuite, is also not new.
But when our newsroom sat down to examine the top stories of the year, one thing stood out: whether it was the Stanley Cup riot, the civic election, Occupy Vancouver or the debate about the proposed downtown casino, social media powered these events and the debates around them to an extent not seen before in this city.
Twitter and even Facebook (which I call a social newspaper) still baffles many of us who otherwise can’t live without websites and email. However, I believe social media is transforming our world in ways we can’t yet fully comprehend. My advice to anyone is to simply try them out. The barrier to entry is very low, provided you have access to the internet.
Here below is my submission to the Vancouver Courier‘s Newsmaker of the Year feature. I encourage you to pick up a copy of the paper or read all the other submissions here.
What made 2011’s headlines about gambling, billion dollar developments, big league sports, riots, political campaigns and demonstrations unique is the new way we chose to discuss them.
The year began with the rancor around a development on the north end of the Cambie Street Bridge. The proposal for an expanded casino next to the renovated B.C. Place stadium had been quietly worked on for years by the time it came to public hearing.
But a grassroots campaign led by former and aspiring politicians rose up in opposition at the eleventh hour. Unlike the casino proponents they crafted their media campaign over blogs and sharp exchanges on Twitter, an evolving and immensely powerful communications tool. They turned public opinion against the expansion with city council approving a zoning for a new, larger casino facility, but without additional slots and tables.
Twitter couldn’t help Luongo’s net-minding skills during the Vancouver Canucks’ playoff run. But thanks to the #Canucks “hashtag” (a phrase combined with a hash, or number, symbol added to a Twitter post, or “tweet”) our hockey success became an even more collective experience.
The social signals were plain as day in the lead up to the Stanley Cup riot on June 15th. One only had to heed the Twitter hashtag #Riot2011 to know trouble was brewing.
As Election Day approached and the #OccupyVancouver movement took over the VAG’s front lawn, it seemed the most fulsome debates were happening online, 140 characters at a time.
For these and many other reasons, Twitter is my Newsmaker of the Year.— Mike Klassen, former NPA city council candidate and CityCaucus.com blogger
boohoo
December 16, 2011 @ 12:46 pm
“neatly tucked inside a plastic bag to protect it from rainwater.”
I would love to read the Courier but it is always left on my front step without a bag so it’s pretty much always wet and unreadable. I’ve actually phoned and asked them to stop, but I guess that got ignored.
Max
December 16, 2011 @ 1:53 pm
Mike:
I couldn’t agree more. Social media has drastically changed the landscape of how people consume information.
I find the ‘snapshots’ that I can pick up on twitter most interesting – as it allows me to track news internationally and quickly. And then there is the interaction part of it.
And speaking of twitter tidbits – this popped up last night….not sure what to make of it:
CityofVancouver City of Vancouver
#streetfoodvancouver Pot Brownies – ideascale.com/t/UEn8ZUJq
1 minute ago
boohoo
December 16, 2011 @ 2:00 pm
I think max’s example is exactly why I don’t follow twitter. Tidbits like that get thrown out and then all sorts of assumptions are made before it is verified as even true or not much less ‘news’. News isn’t rumours. News isn’t ‘I heard that…’
I don’t want my news is 5 second sound bites or 100 character tweets. It’s meaningless without context.
Paul
December 16, 2011 @ 3:58 pm
“Twitter and even Facebook (which I call a social newspaper) still baffles many of us who otherwise can’t live without websites and email. However, I believe social media is transforming our world in ways we can’t yet fully comprehend. My advice to anyone is to simply try them out. The barrier to entry is very low, provided you have access to the internet.”
I agree that we are at the thin edge of the wedge with respect to the impact these social media sites are going to have on the Globe as a whole. However, now would the right time to set a frame work on how and when they are used. I realize that probably goes against the grain of the Internet, but, as bh points out, social media is often mistaken for “fact” or real news (by real, I mean has some set standards for research and fact checking). While I see global connectivity as a very good thing, my personal concern is that social media will dumb down the population as we get too lazy to check facts and accept a tweet as gospel. IMHO, social media is a tool we have made but that we aren’t exactly sure how to use properly…
Julia
December 16, 2011 @ 6:30 pm
I was a Twitter skeptic until I started following hashtags on Tweetdeck.
Hashtags serve as a sort function.
My first experience was to follow #tunisia, #jasminerevolution and #sidibousaid. I watched a country rise up and claim democracy. I have friends in Tunisia that could not access many news sites or relevant information. There were several days where I would use Skype to transmit Twitter posts to let them know what sort of news was coming out of their country. In one instance I suspect I saved a life or two. Then I went on to follow #egypt and #libya. It was incredible to see how long it took for the CBC or CNN to catch up. Yes, sometime the info was wrong… Gaddafi was captured and killed at least 10 times but the insight into what people were thinking and feeling was fascinating and inspiring. There were a couple of nights where I could not leave my computer in case I missed something.
I watched the Canuck riot unfold by tracking 3 hashtags: #YVR,#riot and #canucks. Still trying to figure out why the VPD or the city did not have someone doing similar.
Is much of it rubbish, yes. Will the media ever be the same in the wake of such technology – not a hope.
Ned
December 16, 2011 @ 6:56 pm
Beg to disagree.
IMO Twitter is another time waster in the long list of devices designed to take our focus of what’s important in life.
Take the last election for example. The impact from all the twitter feeds and blog comments were as good as crap.
If out of all media out there, the social media was even 20% influential, we would not have a Vision dominated council and Robertson as Mayor.
Conclusion… nobody paid attention, or if they did, they didn’t give a crap… but if Vancouver Sun or 24 Hours said that NPA and Anton want to curb the Vancouver citizens than… people voted accordingly. 🙁
Steven Forth
December 18, 2011 @ 8:49 am
Vision had every bit as much support on social media as the NPA, probably a lot more. City Caucus is not the only social media source out there and in fact reading on City Caucus reinforced my own decision to vote for Robertson and against Anton. I also voted for Mike Klassen, in large part because he has the most intelligent things to say about zoning and because he is a passionate lover of Vancouver.
Twitter is a tool. It is a useful way to get a stream of consciousness feed from a large number of people, informed people if you are careful who you follow. It is not analysis, or a source of information. It supports awareness and maybe consideration but not understanding. For that we need to invest more time and to dig deeper. This blog is one of many ways to do that.
Max
December 18, 2011 @ 9:28 am
So I am going to derail this post for a moment….to share a Christmas story with you.
This is from my little brother who gave me the perfect Christmas present.
Hi Sis,
Sorry to be a spoil sport and reveal your Christmas present ahead of the holiday, but I figured you would want to know. You told me that you wanted a donation to a charity, to help out someone less fortunate. While waiting to hear back from you I found something myself while downtown. Not sure if you have heard of the “Be a Santa to a Senior” program organized by Home Instead but they operate it throughout the Lower Mainland via businesses such as London Drugs, Save On, and so forth.
You can see the information and a couple of videos here:
http://www.beasantatoasenior.com/
These are elderly people who are basically alone, no family, and no one to provide even the smallest gift. I know there are so many worthy charities to pick from, and quite a few focus (understandably) on families; I think an unfortunate number of these seniors tend to be “last on the list” or forgotten altogether.
The London Drugs here in town had a tree up, and the program ends today. Basically they have a tree set up and there are little cards attached each of which bears a wish from a senior in the community; participants select a card, purchase the wish item or items, and turn it in to the customer service counter who seal it up with the wish card. The Home Instead people collect these, wrap them, and on the 16th give them out. I went to the store this evening and there was one card left on the tree which had not been claimed, a wish from a senior named Allan G. His card was off towards the back of the tree behind a stack of shopping baskets. With two hours left in the day there was a good chance nobody would see it and Allen would have been the one guy who didn’t get his wish acknowledged. He asked for an electric shaver, a toothbrush and toothpaste – so I bought a nice Remington re-chargeable electric shaver, a couple of different toothbrushes, and a couple of things of toothpaste and delivered it to the customer service counter along with the card.
In a few days time an elderly person who most likely had no expectation of being thought of at Christmas is going to receive a nice gift courtesy of you. I didn’t think this could be kept a surprise until Christmas because I figured you would want to know that your wish had been taken care of. I hope you like your gift!
Merry Christmas everyone!
Julia
December 18, 2011 @ 10:06 am
Max, lovely distraction – thank you… sniff, sniff.
My Mom is 93 and well cared for in an AL facility near my home. I see many seniors there that never get visitors and keep thinking that our family should adopt at least one to visit with them and check on them.
These seniors are the lucky ones. The ones you mention are not nearly as blessed. What a great program!
My extended family have been thinking about a gift giving truce for next year. I think you have solved the decision about what to do instead.
thank you!
Ned
December 19, 2011 @ 8:39 pm
Where is Glissy?
Pretty quiet lately. Hope all’s OK.
If you read this … Merry Christmas!
To Mike, Daniel and the rest of the staff at City caucus just the same and all the best for the New Year!
Happy Holidays everyone.
skippy
December 20, 2011 @ 12:42 pm
Off topic but…reading and listening to media reports on the COV costs for occupy vancouver. Seems Gregor and his VV cronies mislead the COV electorate not only on the cost of this but also pending tax increases and COV budget shortfalls. Moreover and indeed sadly, the media reports of the costs of the OV sleepover at the VAG quote Penny Ballem as setting COV costs were in line with other cities. Now, I don’t know if thats true but certainly the VV friendly media simply quoting same, without any investigation or follow up certainly lend credulity to the Ballem quote. Note that at Wholefoods on 4th, when buying groceries, you can donate $2/5/10 to the food bank. The $2.00 will provide one meal. So babysitting the mass pot smoking session during the OV mess amounted to 500,000 food bank meals. i post here to emphasize the necessity of alternate media/social media to counter balance the indolent “mainstream” media.
Happy Hanukkah and Merry Christmas.
Jeff L
December 20, 2011 @ 10:11 pm
The mainstream media I follow gave the city costs for a couple of other locations, I think it was Portland and Seattle.
Given the half million spent on the protest the first weekend, I was pleased to see it was only a million all in. And no violence in ending it.
Max
December 21, 2011 @ 12:04 pm
Personally, I could care less what happens in other areas. I am tired of Vancouver being compared to every other city, especially when it comes to wasteful spending.
Funny, they can spend $1M + (and it will come in at that in the long run), yet they try to screw over the seniors and low income people at the Oly Village.
Max
December 21, 2011 @ 1:17 pm
@skippy:
I see the empty lot at the corner of West 4 and MacDonald is up for development.
A four story mix of residential and commercial space.
I pity anyone who buys/or rents to the back or south bound.
The Rugby House is there and those boys have some blow out parties during the warm weather months.
Yikes!
Glissando Remmy
December 21, 2011 @ 10:26 pm
Right on, Max.
It seems that anything that can move Vision’s agenda forward is OK’d by the cronies in the City Hall and vice-verso. Forget the Riots, the Olly Village, the Olympic Village, the CUPE contracts, the Teachers ‘strike’, the Occupy boo-boo.
When it comes to cutting costs and balancing the budget, the bullies always attack the weakest.
Remember of the Christmas thief that stole the wedding ring from a moribund senior lying on a gurney in a hospital few years ago?
Same here, only the names now are: Vancouver Vision, Enerpro, Aufochs, Penny…
Max
December 22, 2011 @ 9:35 am
Glissy:
You know what bugs me the most about this mess at the Oly Village: is the sense that the City (landlord) is holding the security of these people over their heads.
Johnston stated that if they can’t pay the ‘energy bills’ they would move them out and move someone who could pay the rates in.
Now, these people qualified to live in the Village, based on income. Low income means X dollars. So moving them out and moving others in isn’t going to solve the problem.
The statement by Johnston was just arrogant and heart-less.
Now, after being smacked in the face by the negative media attention – the City has decided that perhaps the ‘system’ was not re-calibrated prior to occupancy.
These units sat empty for how long before people were moved in?? Why, after the first complaints about no heat, no hot water, poor air quality etc came in wasn’t it looked into? After the first complaints of bills of $140+ in one month?
Instead they threaten these people with homelessness, once again.
skippy
December 22, 2011 @ 11:31 am
Because “Glissy” mentioned CUPE, note that CUPE 1004’s collective agreement with the City expires in 9 days. Not a peep, or in the spirit of the season, not a “creature is stirring not even a Meggs” on negotiations to renew the labour contracts. Wonder what the playback to CUPE will be post VV re-election? Max, on the development at 4th and MacDonald, what concerns me is, at least what I have observed, the number of businesses on West 4th that are closing and what appeared to be slow retail sales or the shops. Oddly though, the new bars, both Bimini’s and Ceili’s (7th and Burrard) seem to be doing very well. On Mike’s post above, I do not have a nominee for story of the year in the City, but I have to say ( maybe it was the three spirits that visited me last night in my sleep) one of my favourite City Caucus posts was the February 8th, 2011 link to the anti-bullying flashmob at Oakridge Mall.
Ned
December 22, 2011 @ 8:42 pm
“The statement by Johnston was just arrogant and heart-less.”
What can one expect from a J…oke…erk from Chicago brought on catalog order, via contacts in Hollyhock and Vision?
The man makes $200K plus on my taxes, and yours, and he has the attitude of a landlord from a Dickens book.
18% of Vancouver wanted this punk in, apparently or they voted while intoxicated. It’s going to be three long years of pain, suffering and misery for the majority of inhabitants of this city.
“Instead they threaten these people with homelessness, once again.”
Max, this last statement almost made me look for a pitchfork. The current administration at city hall needs a slap in the face.
Also, Glissy in a previous comment, good analogy with the thief stealing from the weak… wow, aghh..
Max
December 23, 2011 @ 9:22 am
@Ned:
I am meeting a couple at the Oly Village today – delivering a turkey to them for their Christmas dinner.
This senior couple uses the food bank and were unable and/or do not qualify to get a hamper through the Salvation Army as the SA lends support to families first.
After several calls and with the assistance of a reporter that is actively covering the Oly issues, I finally got in touch with them Wednesday.
Jammie Halliday
February 2, 2012 @ 12:26 pm
We’re a bunch of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your website offered us with helpful information to work on. You’ve done an impressive job and our entire community shall be grateful to you.